Subsonic Wind Tunnel

Wind Tunnel Image

Wind Tunnel Image - Tyler Wempe

Introduction

At the end of my junior year of high school, I was thinking of what I was going to do that summer, and I decided to make a wind tunnel. Why you ask? I wanted a project that further challenged my CAD skills and something that kicked off my understanding of electrical engineering. My goal was to finish it that November, just before college applications were due, but that didn't come to fruition. In November, I was still working on the undercarriage of the tunnel where the electronics, load cells, sting mechanism, etc were housed. To this day, I still don't consider it complete, but maybe one day. Below is my journey through this project:

Design Goals

For this project, there was a few key features I wanted to make the project challenging and useful at the end. Here were my main goals with explanations below:

  • Modular Tunnel Sections
  • Large Internal Profile
  • Load Cells
  • Prop Test Module

Modular Tunnel Sections

Firstly, I wanted the tunnel sections to connect and disconnect easily in case of damage and to allow large test subjects to fit into the tunnel. It also allows for upgrades (like adding a second fan). The sections are connected together with 12 bolts along with a TPU seal to prevent the internal airflow from being disrupted.

CAD of Tunnel Section

This is the first full tunnel section, just after the pitot tube.

Large Internal Profile

I've always believed bigger is better, so I wanted to make the tunnel that way. I knew a section would either have to fit entirely on the 256mm x 256mm build plate of my Bambu Lab P1S, or it would have to be broken up in 4 corners to make the tunnel way bigger. I chose the first option because it would be stronger, and 4 corners per section would be a HUGE amount of filament. The design I fell upon has a 218mm x 218mm internal profile, which was unfortunately limited by the bolts/nuts next to the window panes.

Load Cells

I wanted to get actual data when this was done so I decided to put lift and drag load cells into the sting mechanism. These are 5kg load cells reading force forward and backward (drag) and up and down (lift). They are connected to the sting and adjust to give more room for subjects in the tunnel. They are housed in the tunnel underbelly. This design, along with the sting angle mechanism, was tricky because it couldn't simply be mounted directly to the underbelly or the load cells wouldn't give accurate readings. I also added a thrust load cell (10kg) to the propeller testing module in the back of the test section to get propeller data like efficiency. Attached to the load cell mount, are two linear rails for each direction, so both load cells are completely independently from each other. The problem though, is that I got really cheap linear rails that allow the load cell mount to bend slightly when a force is applied. This means the load cells aren't as independent as I designed for.

Image of Propeller Testing Arm

This is the propeller arm. It holds the brushless motor, a hall sensor for rpm calculation, and the thrust load cell.

Prop Test Module

To make the wind tunnel even more useful, I decided to add a propeller testing section with a 1400kv brushless motor. On the backside of the motor, there is a wheel with 2 magnets mounted oppositely for symmetry while the motor spins at high RPM. The RPM is then calculated with a hall sensor near the wheel with magnets. Along with the 10kg thrust load cell, I can measure propeller characteristics such as efficiency.

CAD of Tunnel Propeller Testing Module

This is the propeller section, it has a aerodynamic arm steming from the underbelly that hides the cables and the thrust load cell.

Challenges

With such a big project comes a few problems. Below are the biggest challenges I faced:

  • LED Light Wiring
  • Print Warping
  • Sting System
  • Power Distribution
Image of the Tunnel Lights On

The wind tunnel showing the LED lights on inside the test section

LED Light Wiring

Because each tunnel section needed to be modular, I didn't want the LED strips connected in a chain because I would need a small gauge wire for the early strips in the chain because the LED lights draw a lot of current. I decided to wire each section individually and connect them to the 5V buck converter independently. Then I routed 3 wires through each corner of every section and started the LED strip. This was a very tedious process, but it payed off in the end.

Print Warping

One issue I didn't forsee at all was the warping of the tunnel sections. The printed each section with an internal brim so adhesion wasn't the issue, but it still was warping. The warping force was so strong that it overpowered the magnetic force of the bed plate on my P1S and was lifting up the corners. I think the only way to resolve the issue is to get a good heated enclosure. The prints had so much time to cool down because of the, for some, 30 hour print time so the warping was inevitable with my printer.

Image of Tunnel Angle of Attack and Load Cell Mechanism

The black section is the mechanism. Attached to the linear rail is the crank and slider mechanism that adjusts the angle of attack. On the other side of that (not shown) are the two load cells attached to two linear rails which are attached to the gray body. The entire black section can also slide up or down to give test subjects more room.

Sting System

I would consider the sting system to be my biggest challenge because of all the requirements:

  • Change the Angle of Attack to ±45deg
  • Allow the whole sting to move up or down
  • Apply ALL lift force to the lift load cell
  • Apply ALL thrust force to the thrust load cell
  • Keep the two sting posts the same distance apart

With all these requirements, I worked through many design iterations and did mulitple CAD simulations to ensure this design would work. Below is the image of the design. Not in the picture are, among other things, are two linear rails connected to each load cell so they don't intefere with each other. These rails run perpendicular to each other (like how the load cells are mounted).

CAD of Tunnel Sting and Load Cell Mechanism

The blue section can slide up or down to allow more room for a test subject. The angle of attack is controlled by the crank and slider mechanism which has a servo (not shown).

Image of Subject Mount System

The subject mount, which has two aluminum posts. The right side of the subject mount that connects to the post is supposed to be flipped around so the piece that sticks out hits the boundary button on floor of the tunnel.

Power Distribution

A challenge I am still working on is power distribution. Particularily on the 5V end with the Ardunioo R4 Minima microcontroller. Because the LED lights take so much power, it seems the Ardunio is being starved (but still stays on) because the sensors it is powering turn off (like the pitot sensor). Even though my the LED draw is far less than the 20A maximum of my buck converter (about 12A at full brightness), it somehow isn't getting power. This is an ongoing struggle and I continue to fiddle with capacitors and wiring changes. If you have any ideas please reach out!

Image of Tunnel Underbelly

This is a picture of the tunnel undersection. It showcases all of the wiring.

Pictures

Image of Tunnel Underbelly Microcontroller Section Image of Tunnel App with Tunnel in the Background Image of the Front of Tunnel with Lights On Image of Tunnel Sting with Lights On Image of Tunnel Fan Running Image of Propeller Testing Section with Lights On Image of Test Section from Above Image of Tunnel App Terminal with Data Transmission Image of Tunnel with No Stand Screenshot of Tunnel App on Wind Mode

Videos

Specifications

Item Specification
Main Tunnel Fan 9" Radiator Fan, 1730CFM, 12V 80W
Flow Straighteners Individual ~14.8mm square profile; 140mm long
Test Section Dimensions 900mm x 218mm x 218mm (36in x 8.5in x 8.5in)
Full Dimensions (with Stand) 2.2m (7.4ft) x 0.7m (2.3ft) x 1.3m (4.4ft)
AOA Servo 20g Digital Servo
Main Stability Method Two 22mm diameter stainless steel pipe running parallel with the tunnel
Window Panes 1/4in thick 8x8in plexiglass sheet (not perfectly square)
Max Tunnel Speed 20MPH
Close